Referees Mistakes 🟨 🟥

134
Captain_Emirate
2499 posts Fans' Favourite
edited February 8
I'll try to post many situations which possible to be foul and pk or not. waiting for comments. Agree or not, all comments respected and accepted. People have different observations which make every idea is possible.

Lets begin...

giphy.gif

#1

Tackle from behind, no foul !

.
Post edited by Captain_Emirate on

Comments

  • ICUP
    7636 posts League Winner
    First one is a fair tackle & not a foul
  • Arron xox
    4397 posts National Call-Up
    ICUP wrote: »
    First one is a fair tackle & not a foul

    Are you seriouse ! Watch again. The ball was in front and defender tackled from behind. Both tackles were on my players not on the ball.

    Anyway this guy was an idiot and was tackling whole match. He quit after 4th goal in min80 although his team was full of heros and icons. just got 2 yellow cards with lots of fouls ! Also I got PK without him getting red. These kind of players should not play FUT before learning the basics.

    Not every penalty is a red card even if it's last man, depends if the players intent was to go for the ball or not. And in real life most refs work on double Jeopardy to a certain extent depending on how severe the tackle is
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    Arron xox wrote: »
    ICUP wrote: »
    First one is a fair tackle & not a foul

    Are you seriouse ! Watch again. The ball was in front and defender tackled from behind. Both tackles were on my players not on the ball.

    Anyway this guy was an idiot and was tackling whole match. He quit after 4th goal in min80 although his team was full of heros and icons. just got 2 yellow cards with lots of fouls ! Also I got PK without him getting red. These kind of players should not play FUT before learning the basics.

    Not every penalty is a red card even if it's last man, depends if the players intent was to go for the ball or not. And in real life most refs work on double Jeopardy to a certain extent depending on how severe the tackle is

    I know. This is a game and you got pk even if you don't touch the attacker. Slide tackles from behind on foot in penalty box ! no doubt it is red. I've got red for light push and the players didn't even fall and got red. ! 🟥
  • TopLad69
    210 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    I don't believe this, I get at least 1 red card every other game. Usually a CB but sometimes a CM or ST.

    Yet hold the ball with your keeper, wait for opponent to slide tackle you in frustration and turn last second, it takes 2 or 3 goes to get their player sent off.
  • GitGood
    1237 posts Professional
    Not only fouls, sometimes even offsides are not given..The game have a mind of its own.
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    GitGood wrote: »
    Not only fouls, sometimes even offsides are not given..The game have a mind of its own.

    sometimes offsides are weird ! The ball don't reach behind just the moment you pass then it is offside !

    About fouls sometimes I am in my position and still have the ball in counters, opponent tackle but referee give foul after I pass, even I still have the ball and do attacking chance !
  • Thefranchise92
    11402 posts Has That Special Something
    its becoming an issue, not even cards but just no penalties for blatant penalties on both sides.. stopping play because you think play is gonna be stopped
  • Napolitana
    103 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Mostly a problem with keepers rushing - they can take down the attacker and be no where near the ball … and nothing.
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited January 17
    Napolitana wrote: »
    Mostly a problem with keepers rushing - they can take down the attacker and be no where near the ball … and nothing.

    My GK don't rush only if I assign instruction on him. Even if he has rushes out of goal trait. Imagine he keep on the target line even in crosses and cut-inside passes.
  • You're right Captain, refereeing in the game is a joke when it comes to tackling from behind and penalty decisions.

    I regularly concede penalties despite making clean tackles on ball, really weird refs. 😐
  • Djcat
    730 posts Semi-Pro
    You're right Captain, refereeing in the game is a joke when it comes to tackling from behind and penalty decisions.

    I regularly concede penalties despite making clean tackles on ball, really weird refs. 😐

    EA refs
  • Fifapayne
    7337 posts League Winner
    Clean
  • Prettyfly
    963 posts Professional
    Napolitana wrote: »
    Mostly a problem with keepers rushing - they can take down the attacker and be no where near the ball … and nothing.

    I've been saying for years keepers need to be able to get yellow and red cards. So many fouls from keepers and nothing
  • > @The_Engineer said:
    > You're right Captain, refereeing in the game is a joke when it comes to tackling from behind and penalty decisions.
    >
    > I regularly concede penalties despite making clean tackles on ball, really weird refs. 😐

    Conceding penalties when you don't even press a button annoys the hell out of me.
  • ICUP
    7636 posts League Winner
    ICUP wrote: »
    First one is a fair tackle & not a foul

    Are you seriouse ! Watch again. The ball was in front and defender tackled from behind. Both tackles were on my players not on the ball.

    Anyway this guy was an idiot and was tackling whole match. He quit after 4th goal in min80 although his team was full of heros and icons. just got 2 yellow cards with lots of fouls ! Also I got PK without him getting red. These kind of players should not play FUT before learning the basics.

    He got the ball.

    Just because a tackle is from behind doesn't mean it's a foul, unless you passed the ball to the other CB then he got the ball. Whether it's a foul or not would be depend on whether the game registers contact with the ball first or with ball carrier first.

    Been doing tackles like that since you could play FIFA on PS2
  • ICUP wrote: »
    ICUP wrote: »
    First one is a fair tackle & not a foul

    Are you seriouse ! Watch again. The ball was in front and defender tackled from behind. Both tackles were on my players not on the ball.

    Anyway this guy was an idiot and was tackling whole match. He quit after 4th goal in min80 although his team was full of heros and icons. just got 2 yellow cards with lots of fouls ! Also I got PK without him getting red. These kind of players should not play FUT before learning the basics.

    He got the ball.

    Just because a tackle is from behind doesn't mean it's a foul, unless you passed the ball to the other CB then he got the ball. Whether it's a foul or not would be depend on whether the game registers contact with the ball first or with ball carrier first.

    Been doing tackles like that since you could play FIFA on PS2

    He NEVER got the ball.

    OP must have even seen it using instant replay from various angles, and the video he posted is already enough.

    Stop defending the refereeing in this game, because it's a joke!

  • ICUP
    7636 posts League Winner
    ICUP wrote: »
    ICUP wrote: »
    First one is a fair tackle & not a foul

    Are you seriouse ! Watch again. The ball was in front and defender tackled from behind. Both tackles were on my players not on the ball.

    Anyway this guy was an idiot and was tackling whole match. He quit after 4th goal in min80 although his team was full of heros and icons. just got 2 yellow cards with lots of fouls ! Also I got PK without him getting red. These kind of players should not play FUT before learning the basics.

    He got the ball.

    Just because a tackle is from behind doesn't mean it's a foul, unless you passed the ball to the other CB then he got the ball. Whether it's a foul or not would be depend on whether the game registers contact with the ball first or with ball carrier first.

    Been doing tackles like that since you could play FIFA on PS2

    He NEVER got the ball.

    OP must have even seen it using instant replay from various angles, and the video he posted is already enough.

    Stop defending the refereeing in this game, because it's a joke!

    Speed of the ball when he's dribbling & speed of the ball from the tackle.

    I've already complained about the poor refs & the fact that goalkeepers can save the ball from outside the box with their hands.

    We all know refereeing in the game is poor but doesn't take away from the fact that opposition player got the ball
  • Ballerson
    1721 posts Play-Off Hero
    The poor referees and their programming to not call simple fouls from behind and not to give immediate reds for repeat awful slide tackles from behind makes this game & the gaming experience toxic — this is eas fault as they are the ones programming the refs.

    I just had a guy do three nasty slides from behind and only 1 yellow was given —

    Previous game a dude flipped my forward 2 times and the gk tripped my forward, zero call.

    Toxic game with few consequences for bad in game behavior — until ea is held accountable for it they’ll not change a thing.
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited January 18
    Ballerson wrote: »
    The poor referees and their programming to not call simple fouls from behind and not to give immediate reds for repeat awful slide tackles from behind makes this game & the gaming experience toxic — this is eas fault as they are the ones programming the refs.

    These mistakes are only online. This will not happen in offline game (Squad Battles). As if EA wants these mistakes to be in online matches to make us mad. There are no mistakes FIFA eWorld Cup version of FIFA which make the game perfect then.
    Ballerson wrote: »
    I just had a guy do three nasty slides from behind and only 1 yellow was given —

    Just played a Rival match with opponent who keep juggling the ball and lob passes, make his players bouncy. Keep loosing the ball ! Then I did skill moves and he keep sliding, without me getting fouls ! I did skill with GK. Then he bring back to his keeper to make skills ! as if he wants to beat me in skill moves !! was tied 3-3 in 80th min and with his dirty slide I got PK, scored and waste time behind then won.

    This guy done more than 5 times and only be given 2 yellows. I really don't enjoy the game when newbies slides, even if I win. Also it is common who keep do skill moves without pressing and don't have basic skills in passing or defending, drop back and offside-trap. They are just street footballers who just dance around the pitch.

    Guys if you want to do skill moves, get in volta mode which contains additional skills there. FUT is not suitable for making a show.
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited February 8
    giphy.gif

    #2

    silly pk against me which wasn't on the opponent. He just fall down on my cb after shot.
    Post edited by Captain_Emirate on
  • TomNXT1
    40 posts Last Pick at the Park
    coz the game sucks
  • The_giant616
    2097 posts Fans' Favourite
    giphy.gif

    silly pk against me which wasn't on the opponent. He just fall down on my cb after shot.

    These are the worst and it happens all of the time. It’s extremely rare for a red to give a pen after the ❤️❤️❤️❤️ is taken. Non existent if the player shoots and randomly falls over a defender
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited February 8
    giphy.gif

    #3

    This should be pk, !
    Post edited by Captain_Emirate on
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited February 8
    giphy.gif

    #4

    This is Foul !
    Post edited by Captain_Emirate on
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited February 8
    giphy.gif

    #5

    Foul !
    but not because he is Fool !
    Post edited by Captain_Emirate on
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited January 18
    Show us yours which make you mad on game.

    Use GIPHY app to convert from mp4 to gif.
    Only 6.5 sec allowed.
  • TomNXT1
    40 posts Last Pick at the Park
    what do you expect from 20years old game
  • Captain_Emirate
    2499 posts Fans' Favourite
    TomNXT1 wrote: »
    what do you expect from 20years old game

    30 years, as my old brother play FIFA 93 on SEGA :p
  • Fifapayne
    7337 posts League Winner
    giphy.gif

    silly pk against me which wasn't on the opponent. He just fall down on my cb after shot.

    Let’s see. You make a poorly timed tackle(we can clearly see the animation) and as a result the guy trips over your back foot..it’s a pen.
    giphy.gif

    This should be pk, !

    Why is this a pen? He clearly gets the ball and ends up smashing you after. Another clean tackle.
    giphy.gif

    This is Foul !

    This should be a foul.
    giphy.gif

    Foul !
    but not because he is Fool !

    Looks like he’s on your back and you dribble back down and left and the ball hits his foot.


    I know you won’t agree but those are my observations.
Sign In or Register to comment.