Rate your reds

Sctt78
157 posts Has Potential To Be Special
Interested to see what people have pulled and ended up using.

Community - G2
Tagliafico - 114 games, absolute pit bull
Areola - 2 games, same as all other keepers

Prem - G2
Fofana - 5 games, solid
Ederson - 3 games, no comment.

La liga - G2
Oblak - not used
Fekir - 10 games, used for Isak obj and seemed decent enough but didn’t stand out.

All in all, 3 weekends grinded for a decent left back and SBC foder.

Comments

  • Jordonp
    452 posts Sunday League Hero
    Community - G3

    Illic - Great fodder
    Can’t remember - Also great fodder

    Prem - G2

    Rashford - Prolific, something like 40 games 70 goals
    Banega - Decent player but hard to get in teams past likes of mid Gullit, Renato, Vidal, Essien etc. However I’m building up a stack of Argentinians so can see future use for him

    La Liga - G2

    Varane - Sank to G3 using him this WL - took a while to get used to but getting the hang of him now
    Oblak - Used as fodder in Desailly along with the blue card I also had after the Courtois SBC came out.
  • TheonlywayisS6
    3341 posts National Call-Up
    edited May 17
    I've only ever got 2 reds that I've actually used for any length of time, 88 Vardy several months ago but he's not made my squad screen for a couple of months now, and Dias from PL TOTS. Dias is very good, will be using for the foreseeable.

    My TOTS reds have been:

    Ivan Toney (from S1)

    Ruben Dias and Gundogan

    2 x Turkish League, didn't even get offered a La Liga. Think they were probably a couple of the highest rated ones, but still fuming.
  • Jordonp
    452 posts Sunday League Hero
    Sctt78 wrote: »
    Interested to see what people have pulled and ended up using.

    Community - G2
    Tagliafico - 114 games, absolute pit bull
    Areola - 2 games, same as all other keepers

    Prem - G2
    Fofana - 5 games, solid
    Ederson - 3 games, no comment.

    La liga - G2
    Oblak - not used
    Fekir - 10 games, used for Isak obj and seemed decent enough but didn’t stand out.

    All in all, 3 weekends grinded for a decent left back and SBC foder.


    If you like Tagliafico, Alba is very similar but better in every way
  • kraid
    7439 posts League Winner
    Jordonp wrote: »
    Community - G3

    Illic - Great fodder
    Can’t remember - Also great fodder

    Prem - G2

    Rashford - Prolific, something like 40 games 70 goals
    Banega - Decent player but hard to get in teams past likes of mid Gullit, Renato, Vidal, Essien etc. However I’m building up a stack of Argentinians so can see future use for him

    La Liga - G2

    Varane - Sank to G3 using him this WL - took a while to get used to but getting the hang of him now
    Oblak - Used as fodder in Desailly along with the blue card I also had after the Courtois SBC came out.

    Packing rashford and varane is ridiculous 😵
  • BALDUIN
    412 posts Sunday League Hero
    edited May 17
    I'm similar to you, most fodder apart from the pitbull known as Tag and the flying Spanish man (Navas), otherwise all fodder from G1 finishes

    My team is only untradeable so would be nice to get some top ones (prays for Sancho)
  • Sctt78
    157 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Jordonp wrote: »
    Sctt78 wrote: »
    Interested to see what people have pulled and ended up using.

    Community - G2
    Tagliafico - 114 games, absolute pit bull
    Areola - 2 games, same as all other keepers

    Prem - G2
    Fofana - 5 games, solid
    Ederson - 3 games, no comment.

    La liga - G2
    Oblak - not used
    Fekir - 10 games, used for Isak obj and seemed decent enough but didn’t stand out.

    All in all, 3 weekends grinded for a decent left back and SBC foder.


    If you like Tagliafico, Alba is very similar but better in every way

    He would definitely be my go to if it wasn’t for chem. Tag gets my Klaiber on 7 chem as I’m yet to find anyone that does a better job at CB than him.
  • SanderFC
    3232 posts National Call-Up
    Community/EFL:
    - Alaba (86 games, 3g3a)
    - Barnes (89 games, 55g38a)
    Great players: Alaba is great with the ball although would have been better with a non-lean body type, Barnes felt unstoppable in the first 20 games but dropped wrt impact after that.

    PL/Saudi:
    - Guanca: was nice in squad battles

    LaLiga/SuperLig:
    - Marcao: was nice in squad battles

    Couldn't play a lot in the weekends after Community, so only got to S3 to get 'a' chance for some nice <89 gem but not really succeeded in that. Got to G2 this weekend, so hopefully I get lucky again when I have two picks
  • nj10
    2853 posts National Call-Up
    Community

    Barnes decent lw- can play in the middle of the park aswell
    Bailey : good sub

    Epl
    Gundogan
    Ederson- average gk saved me in one game

    La Liga/ Turkish
    Casemiro
    Biglia

    3/6 I get use out of so not bad but none are great
  • Mmandras
    5169 posts Big Money Move
    0 reds, didn't play WL since TOTS because of arhtiris, but slowly recovering so might be fit until EURO/Summe heat.

    Truth be told, and strangely, I miss the WL and competition, I don't mind the reds since so many great cheap cards are available after TOTS it won't be critical.
  • futaddict79
    2124 posts Fans' Favourite
    Community reds - G2


    Ndombele and areola

    Use neither

    Prem - G3

    Ederson and shaw

    Shaws good but still using mendy due to the below

    La liga - G3

    90 rate Turkish player and Varane

    Varene is in my main squad and is awesome
  • SupaNoodle1990
    31453 posts National Team Captain
    edited May 17
    Community gold 2

    Areola & Nkunku - already foddered.

    Prem gold 2

    Gundogan & Dias - both in main team

    La Liga gold 2

    Carrasco & Oblak - both in main team

    Very happy with mine.
  • MIG40970
    683 posts An Exciting Prospect
    PL G2
    Gundogan
    Soucek

    not using them

    LaLiga G3
    Llorente 9/10 - CDM in 352 (next to PIM Essien)
    Navas 8/10 - CB in 352 (with Y. Berchiche and FB Pique)
    both were in one of my WL squads this weekend with score 11-4
  • Pocketsquareguy
    7293 posts League Winner
    Community G2
    Taglifico
    Ndombele

    Prem G2
    Fofana
    Romarinho

    La Liga G3
    Carrasco
    Casemiro

    I would say overall I’m happy. Casemiro and fofana are the only two that serve me no use currently.
  • greif44
    5466 posts Big Money Move
    Community G2
    Hughes and Ilicic. Both went straight to Aguero.

    PL - had to skip it.

    La Liga G3
    90 Brazilian LW and Casemiro. First went to Pique; Casemiro got to play last WL and will stay for a bit.
  • deelio
    754 posts Semi-Pro
    Gold 2 every week
    89 nkunku 88 edouard - used nkunku for bundesliga objective he's decent
    94 ederson 89 fofana - put ederson in sbc, used fofana last 2 weeks been decent nothing special, will replace with de jong at cb to fit coutinho
    90 moreno 91 biglia - sbc fodder
    I challenge anyone to show me worse picks from gold 2 😂😂😂
  • Seeleyjs17
    1018 posts Professional
    Best reds from tots ive used are striker rohmerino and biglia as a box to box. No main league reds had been good so used for fodder still have red casimireo tried to use but didnt get along with him
  • Rainaz
    665 posts An Exciting Prospect
    Screenshot-20210518-070642-Companion.jpg

    Not TOTS specific but this guy I've had for a long time and is still the best I used! Almost 1k goals never done that before.

    Best pulls from Tots reds are:

    Dias- wall, nothing more to be said

    Fofana- sbc fodder

    Shaw- decent at LB but better at CB

    Vazquez- incredible at CM
  • Joe_the_chef22
    572 posts An Exciting Prospect
    My reds been awful all year not one decent card 3 tots all lower league not one .mayor league option at silver 1 for 3 weeks lol
Sign In or Register to comment.