If Ronaldo & Messi were...

13
EekAlaska
1646 posts Play-Off Hero
Icons what would their three versions be rated and what positions?

Comments

  • Lionelil
    144 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Since ronaold is the most over rated player ever.
  • EekAlaska
    1646 posts Play-Off Hero
    Lionelil wrote: »
    Since ronaold is the most over rated player ever.

    This must be a troll comment to bait someone into a response
  • Lionelil
    144 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    EekAlaska wrote: »
    Lionelil wrote: »
    Since ronaold is the most over rated player ever.

    This must be a troll comment to bait someone into a response

    It ain't.
  • KinggHuss
    2049 posts Fans' Favourite
    Messi:

    92 CF
    95 RW
    98 CF

    Ronaldo:

    91 LW
    94 ST
    97 LW
  • FifaTaco
    932 posts Semi-Pro
    KinggHuss wrote: »
    Messi:

    92 CF
    95 RW
    98 CF

    Ronaldo:

    91 LW
    94 ST
    97 LW

    Spot on although I think ea will make them equal prime rating if ea are even still running when they retire :lol:
  • Skboseph
    318 posts Sunday League Hero
    Ronaldo already surpassed Messi 4-1 comeback and 4/5 last ucl.. got club legends calling you out ... Ronaldo has to be 98 on his prime and baby Ronaldo would be a RW like he was in the beginning at Manchester 😂
  • Lionelil
    144 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Caiden wrote: »
    Lionelil wrote: »
    Messi 97 98 99
    Ronaldo 84 86 85

    And in game Ronaldo would still crap all over Messi.

    Cause they still haven't figured out how to make Messi's wisdom and geniuses on FIFA
    U can't really put them on the same league in real life, in 30 years people will laugh a when anyone trys to compare Ronaldo to Messi
  • KinggHuss
    2049 posts Fans' Favourite
    Skboseph wrote: »
    Ronaldo already surpassed Messi

    No.
    Skboseph wrote: »
    baby Ronaldo would be a RW like he was in the beginning at Manchester 😂

    Yes.
  • VioIent_Storm
    23 posts Last Pick at the Park
    KinggHuss wrote: »
    Messi:

    92 CF
    95 RW
    98 CF

    Ronaldo:

    91 LW
    94 ST
    97 LW

    I’d go for this, seems the most likely
  • Lionelil
    144 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Ip
  • Springveldt
    4508 posts National Call-Up
    I'd argue that Prime Messi should be 99 since that 2012 season were he scored 91 goals in a single year will probably never be done in my lifetime again.
  • Lionelil
    144 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    I'd argue that Prime Messi should be 99 since that 2012 season were he scored 91 goals in a single year will probably never be done in my lifetime again.

    Fine then.
    Messi versions:
    97
    99
    99.
  • Lionelil
    144 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Momus wrote: »
    Messi hasn’t tested himself in a proper league.

    Look at Ronaldo, gone to a small club in the serie A and has managed to get them top of league. Now that’s a proper challenge.

    U literally have no clue about football .
    Maybe I'm too anti CR7 but still he speaks about moving to juventus cause he seeks a challenge?
    Srsly juventus is one of the best club in the world with a few amazing players in every position.
  • Momus
    1830 posts Play-Off Hero
    Lionelil wrote: »
    Momus wrote: »
    Messi hasn’t tested himself in a proper league.

    Look at Ronaldo, gone to a small club in the serie A and has managed to get them top of league. Now that’s a proper challenge.

    U literally have no clue about football .
    Maybe I'm too anti CR7 but still he speaks about moving to juventus cause he seeks a challenge?
    Srsly juventus is one of the best club in the world with a few amazing players in every position.

    Sorry I was being sarcastic.

    I don’t see how it’s a challenge at all going to a club that’s won the league 7 years in a row.

  • Lionelil
    144 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Sarcastic level: legendary
  • HelloDearie
    2238 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited February 4
    Momus wrote: »
    Messi hasn’t tested himself in a proper league.

    Look at Ronaldo, gone to a small club in the serie A and has managed to get them top of league. Now that’s a proper challenge.

    :D
  • TopCat
    533 posts An Exciting Prospect
    Momus wrote: »
    Lionelil wrote: »
    Momus wrote: »
    Messi hasn’t tested himself in a proper league.

    Look at Ronaldo, gone to a small club in the serie A and has managed to get them top of league. Now that’s a proper challenge.

    U literally have no clue about football .
    Maybe I'm too anti CR7 but still he speaks about moving to juventus cause he seeks a challenge?
    Srsly juventus is one of the best club in the world with a few amazing players in every position.

    Sorry I was being sarcastic.

    I don’t see how it’s a challenge at all going to a club that’s won the league 7 years in a row.

    The challenge is to take them to champions league title.

    Can’t see how anyone can play down Ronaldo’s achievements. All those Champions leagues won where his goal ratio is smashing allcomers
  • BigEneh
    125 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Lionelil wrote: »
    Momus wrote: »
    Messi hasn’t tested himself in a proper league.

    Look at Ronaldo, gone to a small club in the serie A and has managed to get them top of league. Now that’s a proper challenge.

    U literally have no clue about football .
    Maybe I'm too anti CR7 but still he speaks about moving to juventus cause he seeks a challenge?
    Srsly juventus is one of the best club in the world with a few amazing players in every position.

    Wooooosshh
  • Zakury
    694 posts An Exciting Prospect
    Ronaldos baby version should be RW when he was top scorer in Prem at like 19
  • marvson
    279 posts Sunday League Hero
    Lionelil wrote: »
    Sarcastic level: legendary

    Such a stupid fanboy.. the only who doesnt have a clue about Football is u.. both are brilliant players and they should be rated the same.
  • Mini_Miudo
    9962 posts Has That Special Something
    Ngl, if Pele's 98, Ronaldo and Messi should both be 99 in their prime. No one, and I mean NO ONE, comes close. 10 years of Ballon d'Or going exclusively to them with 5 a piece. Can't see that happening ever again.
  • MHoney1234
    7680 posts League Winner
    edited February 4
    KinggHuss wrote: »
    Messi:

    92 CF
    95 RW
    98 CF

    Ronaldo:

    91 LW
    94 ST
    97 LW

    Neither would be above 96 if icons. On par with R9 imo
  • MHoney1234
    7680 posts League Winner
    Mini_Miudo wrote: »
    Ngl, if Pele's 98, Ronaldo and Messi should both be 99 in their prime. No one, and I mean NO ONE, comes close. 10 years of Ballon d'Or going exclusively to them with 5 a piece. Can't see that happening ever again.

    How many world cups between them?
  • Mini_Miudo
    9962 posts Has That Special Something
    MHoney1234 wrote: »
    KinggHuss wrote: »
    Messi:

    92 CF
    95 RW
    98 CF

    Ronaldo:

    91 LW
    94 ST
    97 LW

    Neither would be above 96 if icons

    Omegalul
  • BPLosers
    157 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    FifaTaco wrote: »
    KinggHuss wrote: »
    Messi:

    92 CF
    95 RW
    98 CF

    Ronaldo:

    91 LW
    94 ST
    97 LW

    Spot on although I think ea will make them equal prime rating if ea are even still running when they retire :lol:

    Oh they’ll still be running and pushing out the same **** product year after year thanks to all the morons on this forum dumping thousands of dollars on FIFA Points every year.
  • MHoney1234
    7680 posts League Winner
    edited February 4
    Mini_Miudo wrote: »
    MHoney1234 wrote: »
    KinggHuss wrote: »
    Messi:

    92 CF
    95 RW
    98 CF

    Ronaldo:

    91 LW
    94 ST
    97 LW

    Neither would be above 96 if icons

    Omegalul

    If you think these guys are better than the R9 in his prime (I think they’re on par btw), you must be under 20 years old. It’s cool mate, I don’t judge, you can only see what you know.
  • Mini_Miudo
    9962 posts Has That Special Something
    MHoney1234 wrote: »
    Mini_Miudo wrote: »
    Ngl, if Pele's 98, Ronaldo and Messi should both be 99 in their prime. No one, and I mean NO ONE, comes close. 10 years of Ballon d'Or going exclusively to them with 5 a piece. Can't see that happening ever again.

    How many world cups between them?

    That's a team award, it's a team sport. Guess Giroud's better than both then? Put Mbappe in the Portuguese/Argentinian team and he wouldn't have won it either, even though everyone seems to think he deserved a spot in TOTY because he was lucky to be born French while Salah was born Egyptian. :lol:
Sign In or Register to comment.