Mbappe or Bale

Wonderfulwest

Ok so I’ve just packed Mbappe but dosnt really fit my team so would be a KO Sub. So question is who’s better Bale or Mbappe both are rapid goal scoring machines but would be playing RM as I don’t like the right Forwards

maXmood

i have CL Mbappe and i can say that Fred/Fabinho can catch up with him.. i think he's flawed..

however, on the good side, he's a good poucher/finisher..

haven't tried bale yet.

Wonderfulwest

maXmood wrote: »

i have CL Mbappe and i can say that Fred/Fabinho can catch up with him.. i think he's flawed..

however, on the good side, he's a good poucher/finisher..

haven't tried bale yet.

I’ll try him out see what he feels like, just always felt mbappe was just pace nothing more. Apon looking at my coins I might sell up and look an icon, tho bake always seems to tear me up when I face him reason I asked

Sercs

Mbappe is superb, feels Elite.

Bale is whole package and better in bad gameplay imo. Mbappe has great links though whereas Bale not so much

ThomasFußballgott

Sercs wrote: »

Mbappe is superb, feels Elite.

Bale is whole package and better in bad gameplay imo. Mbappe has great links though whereas Bale not so much

Modric, Kroos?

PelzyWelzy

Used both quite extensively (packed Bale week 1)...

Always go back to Bale.

Ch1cha

ThomasFußballgott wrote: »

Sercs wrote: »

Mbappe is superb, feels Elite.

Bale is whole package and better in bad gameplay imo. Mbappe has great links though whereas Bale not so much

Modric, Kroos?

Neither a meta proof, don't think I ever come across one of these. I agree with that guy.

I would prefer Mbappe as a winger but Bale as a striker or RF simply because of his strength and ability to hold the ball well between defenders. Mbappe is more agile and easier to do skillmoves with so more suitable as a winger.

So to OP, I would choose Mbappe in your situation

Campino

Mbappe is unreal

knightrider

Mbappe is lit for me.

but bale is more well rounded cause of the sheer pace coupled with strength he got. he's really good upfront.

Wonderfulwest

Thanks for all the input guys, I’m gonna test out Mbappe and see how he does playing LW.

Noo

Report back because I'm looking to do something similar. Play Mbappe on left cam position in a 4231.

One of Mbappe/Bale/Neymar is comming into my team and Mbappe fits the best for chem so I'm hoping it works well for you and you can in turn convince me lol.

Let us know how it goes.

Sketchh34

Ch1cha wrote: »

ThomasFußballgott wrote: »

Sercs wrote: »

Mbappe is superb, feels Elite.

Bale is whole package and better in bad gameplay imo. Mbappe has great links though whereas Bale not so much

Modric, Kroos?

Neither a meta proof, don't think I ever come across one of these. I agree with that guy.

I would prefer Mbappe as a winger but Bale as a striker or RF simply because of his strength and ability to hold the ball well between defenders. Mbappe is more agile and easier to do skillmoves with so more suitable as a winger.

So to OP, I would choose Mbappe in your situation

dude modric is a machine...and kroos was fantastic when i need the perfect pass.

AnDrEwThEdOn

Mbappe

Navraat

Mbappe, killing it at LST in 41212(2)

He clutches it in a team eith Raul and Neymar

Tsarov

Bale better at ST, Mbappe LW/RW. But Bale has 3* weak foot and it may be really frustrating from time to time.

Wonderfulwest

Well from LM Mbappe is not only creating a lot of chances. His scoring some lovely goals, with having him in the side opens up Messi and POTM Auba more so I have more threats going forward. Very tempted to keep him, he isn’t just a one trick pony his got a locker full

maXmood

Wonderfulwest wrote: »

Well from LM Mbappe is not only creating a lot of chances. His scoring some lovely goals, with having him in the side opens up Messi and POTM Auba more so I have more threats going forward. Very tempted to keep him, he isn’t just a one trick pony his got a locker full

@Wonderfulwest
care to share your team/formation plz?

Wonderfulwest

maXmood wrote: »

Wonderfulwest wrote: »

Well from LM Mbappe is not only creating a lot of chances. His scoring some lovely goals, with having him in the side opens up Messi and POTM Auba more so I have more threats going forward. Very tempted to keep him, he isn’t just a one trick pony his got a locker full

@Wonderfulwest
care to share your team/formation plz?

What’s a good quick image uploaded ?

maXmood

Wonderfulwest wrote: »

maXmood wrote: »

Wonderfulwest wrote: »

Well from LM Mbappe is not only creating a lot of chances. His scoring some lovely goals, with having him in the side opens up Messi and POTM Auba more so I have more threats going forward. Very tempted to keep him, he isn’t just a one trick pony his got a locker full

@Wonderfulwest
care to share your team/formation plz?

What’s a good quick image uploaded ?

i use Gyazo

Wonderfulwest

maXmood wrote: »

Wonderfulwest wrote: »

Well from LM Mbappe is not only creating a lot of chances. His scoring some lovely goals, with having him in the side opens up Messi and POTM Auba more so I have more threats going forward. Very tempted to keep him, he isn’t just a one trick pony his got a locker full

@Wonderfulwest
care to share your team/formation plz?

Wonderfulwest

Carlos181

Idk what people are talking about. Bale is amazing at RM for me. Fast, can cut in for finesse or near post power shot. Or Coutinho cross to him far post, and wins the header over my opponents fullback every time.

Noo

Carlos181 wrote: »

Idk what people are talking about. Bale is amazing at RM for me. Fast, can cut in for finesse or near post power shot. Or Coutinho cross to him far post, and wins the header over my opponents fullback every time.

Bale being strong in the air is the main reason I'm still tempted to go for him over Mbappe. Mbappe is still favourite though.

Navraat

Mbappe, 5* skills and 4* weakfoot with Finesse trait

Mr. Soper

Have them both. Bale is way better, just stronger on the ball.

Finesse_4days

I find Bale trash as a winger becuase of the 3* weakfoot and clunky dribble , but good as a stiker becuase of the pace, strength and heading, he would also be good as a LCM in a 41212. Mbappe not so good at striker, but much better than Bale as a winger or wide cam.

DWR

Love Bale as my RM in a 4411. Swaps to ST if I need too.

xGrumpyWolfx

Only used Bale but he's hella sluggish in poor gameplay when the servers suck, his finesse shots are OP though

GeTRiGhT

Bale tore me a new one the other night

GeTRiGhT

Tried Bale after he tore me up...

Didn't do crap...bought Mbappe back...so much better for me.