833 posts Semi-Pro
I want a second cd next to david luiz. How is if naldo? Or is nif silva or marquinhos better?


  • Thermae
    211 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Also suffering from the same dilemma! Following this post.....
  • dylanmx
    4427 posts National Call-Up
    He's great used him for a while and he was a beast.
  • fluffymnuffy
    12531 posts Has That Special Something
    he's 6' 6"
  • MxM15
    833 posts Semi-Pro
    he's 6' 6"

    What do you mean? Good or bad in fifa 18 LOL
  • Mdx
    2691 posts Fans' Favourite
    edited February 2018
    Havent used him because of his workrates.
    High attack rate on a cb is a big no no.
  • Bavarian89
    311 posts Sunday League Hero
    SIF Naldo is gret. Had him for like 100 games and then switched to IF Benatia because i wanted Nainggolan in my team. And for me SIF Naldo is better than Benatia.
  • pekkaa88
    6024 posts Big Money Move
    The **** is Luiz doing in your team? He is the worst CB/ST in the game
  • Damo_Suzuki
    2054 posts Fans' Favourite
    I was worried about SIF Naldo's work rates and lack of acceleration but he is awesome for me. He doesnt rush out of defence at all. Used him so i could get SIF Telles at LB and i have him next to Boateng. It is my favourite CB pairing so far.
  • Tennster10
    1906 posts Play-Off Hero
    Following this. Want to build a brazil team
  • Sumitro
    587 posts An Exciting Prospect
    I have never used Naldo but I suppose Ginter is much better. When using Shadow, Ginter’s Defending becomes 99, and he is 188cm with M/M workrate
  • bberger
    5164 posts Big Money Move
    Depends on how you like to use him and the players around him.

    Had his SIF in a 4atb with Boateng and he was a disgrace. Always pushed up too much and left gaps between him and Boateng.

    - paired with another H/M in a 4atb he's bossing it if you don't sit back.
    - as a central CB in a 3atb or 5atb he is just perfect! Best CCB out there hands down. He ALWAYS is exactly where he should be. Just a little bit iñ front of the other 2 CBs filling the gap between the CMs and CBs. Wouldn't trade him for the world there.
  • CtldChaos
    2056 posts Fans' Favourite
    pekkaa88 wrote: »
    The **** is Luiz doing in your team? He is the worst CB/ST in the game

    This. Tried him for 3 games so I could get SIF Telles in there.... as good as Telles is Luiz is a major liability back there.
  • MxM15
    833 posts Semi-Pro
    edited February 2018
    Who from the brazil cb’s would you choose over luiz then?
  • Persevere80
    1095 posts Professional
    I bought him during lunar New year and have rotated him between ginter and boateng. I'm considering selling him. Can anyone say if his price has went up due to a possible upgrade?
  • Krislar
    450 posts Sunday League Hero
    Never used him, was looking at him but his jumping put me off, can't remember the figure but it's shockingly low.. Had visions of him being glued to the floor during any crosses in to the box...

    Not sure if it even matter in game though being 6'6"
  • Hive
    662 posts An Exciting Prospect
    Naldo SIF, Luiz and Thiago Silva are all great Brazilian CB's. Once Marquinhos gets an IF, he'll be right up there as well, I imagine. His NIF is pretty good as is.
  • Nessy
    1891 posts Fans' Favourite
    I have SIF next to David Luiz.
    Great pairing when Luiz stays back.
    Gone to Silva today to see how he works.
    Failing that will go for an icon.
Sign In or Register to comment.