Should Antonio Valencia be in FIFA 18 TOTY?

13
mHazard
13787 posts Has That Special Something
edited January 2018

Should Antonio Valencia be in FIFA 18 TOTY? 292 votes

Yes
27%
Gale420S-DogLewisT91Boysie91ShaneTescoi2-TempZ-2itruegunn3rSudjinnMr. SoperPangolinImpressive TackleRedArmyDoofAntparry92LiamoooTjahrfluffymnuffyDenisianesdwaynethepainSPAMPEBS 81 votes
No
63%
simsiegMartRulisteningHicksy2011I SiR MartY ILiveArsenalDandingoooNornIronBarslundSkorpio_KingG000nerOnedoesntsimplyNurDerHSV_Drobo VaaassMr_Don123Orange PrinceLiam Wdannyboyz ginga ninja xrckstr 186 votes
Right back position should be some CB player
8%
DawudRonaldoSmudgeJayyThunderLloydieslicknickmarvsonDG4KHSwissymHazardThi-GerlucasGoodnightIreneKingEric66TSpiers1UKXx_iou_cheesecake_xXaditya_beckham23Tornado31619E_clipZeAndrew79 25 votes

Comments

  • Baddest_cubza_1
    3653 posts National Call-Up
    No
    I just don’t think he warrants it, he’s going to get in because he’s good on Fifa
  • Neckabob
    14555 posts Has That Special Something
    No
    I just don’t think he warrants it, he’s going to get in because he’s good on Fifa

  • Dawud
    16137 posts World Class
    Right back position should be some CB player
    Only united fans and WL players want him, fact
  • mHazard
    13787 posts Has That Special Something
    Right back position should be some CB player
    Dawud wrote: »
    Only united fans and WL players want him, fact

    Agree tbh
  • Retro_G
    33023 posts National Team Captain
    edited January 2018
    Yes
    This poll will just show you the amount of bitter anti United haters on here. Valencia won the youtube votes, that was a much larger sample size with millions of subscribers. EA would be mad to go against the community vote. They would get a huge backlash for not listening to the community.
  • Pughy30
    30878 posts National Team Captain
    No
    Retro_G wrote: »
    This poll just show you the amount of bitter anti United haters on here. Valencia won the youtube votes, that was a much larger sample size with millions of subscribers. EA would be mad to go against the community vote. They would get a huge backlash for not listening to the community.

    The United victim card :sleeping:
  • Denisianes
    8164 posts League Winner
    Yes
    Wouldn't mind Kimmich, but his chances are a bit lower. I doubt that the actual players care much about this "award" so I see nothing wrong with getting a solid player in fifa. It's not some exceptional real life recognition or something.
  • Mr_Don123
    2282 posts Fans' Favourite
    No
    How can Valencia be in instead of Carvajal who has been essential to Real Madrid's success?
  • TwoZebras
    6741 posts Big Money Move
    edited January 2018
    No
    It's a joke he's even in contention really but there you go
  • Antparry92
    21055 posts Club Captain
    Yes
    It’s either between him or Kimmich.
  • Radraptor
    1946 posts Fans' Favourite
    No
    Retro_G wrote: »
    This poll just show you the amount of bitter anti United haters on here. Valencia won the youtube votes, that was a much larger sample size with millions of subscribers. EA would be mad to go against the community vote. They would get a huge backlash for not listening to the community.

    First of all, him winning the YouTube votes means nothing other than a bunch of streamers like to use him in a video game. The reality is, he is not even close to the best RB in the game in real life. Carvajal and Alves are both better. Lastly, I don’t know where you have been but EA could care less about any backlash from the community as they routinely make terrible decisions that the community rages over and make no changes about it.
  • Pughy30
    30878 posts National Team Captain
    No
    the youtube votes were done by their 12yr old subs who takes that ❤️❤️❤️❤️ seriously :joy:
  • Swissy
    2687 posts Fans' Favourite
    Right back position should be some CB player
    Personally I’d rather see a 3atb consisting of Ramos Marcelo bonucci and an extra midfielder but obvs that not gonna happen so extra cb for me
  • Viggo 007
    12248 posts Has That Special Something
    edited January 2018
    No
    But this is FIFA and a TOTY Valencia looks more appealing than TOTY Carvajal tbf
  • Sirin
    2527 posts Fans' Favourite
    Yes
    Best RB in the premier league but not in the world.

    Would like that card though :)
  • RadioShaq
    21271 posts Moderator
    What are the rules when voting? Are youtubers allowed to vote for anyone for any reason?
  • Radraptor
    1946 posts Fans' Favourite
    No
    Viggo 007 wrote: »
    But this is FIFA and a TOTY Valencia looks more appealing than TOTY Carvajal tbf

    If that was the logic then Ronaldo and Messi wouldn’t even make it as much more people play with Jesus, Martial, and Mbappe. It’s the TOTY in real life. Not TOTY for FIFA WL
  • Pughy30
    30878 posts National Team Captain
    No
    RadioShaq wrote: »
    What are the rules when voting? Are youtubers allowed to vote for anyone for any reason?

    Some have done it themselves but a few have let their subs vote, One of the spanish youtubers who let their subs vote has players like Isco in his team so it's just a mess
  • Kellnerr
    5484 posts Big Money Move
    No
    Swissy wrote: »
    Personally I’d rather see a 3atb consisting of Ramos Marcelo bonucci and an extra midfielder but obvs that not gonna happen so extra cb for me

    Bonucci hasn't been that great last year.
  • mHazard
    13787 posts Has That Special Something
    Right back position should be some CB player
    Kellnerr wrote: »
    Swissy wrote: »
    Personally I’d rather see a 3atb consisting of Ramos Marcelo bonucci and an extra midfielder but obvs that not gonna happen so extra cb for me

    Bonucci hasn't been that great last year.

    Next joke please
  • Retro_G
    33023 posts National Team Captain
    edited January 2018
    Yes
    Radraptor wrote: »
    Retro_G wrote: »
    This poll just show you the amount of bitter anti United haters on here. Valencia won the youtube votes, that was a much larger sample size with millions of subscribers. EA would be mad to go against the community vote. They would get a huge backlash for not listening to the community.

    First of all, him winning the YouTube votes means nothing other than a bunch of streamers like to use him in a video game. The reality is, he is not even close to the best RB in the game in real life. Carvajal and Alves are both better. Lastly, I don’t know where you have been but EA could care less about any backlash from the community as they routinely make terrible decisions that the community rages over and make no changes about it.

    Most the youtubers done straw polls, had their subscribers vote. Yes EA have made some strange decisions with regards to TOTW over the years, but they don't ask for community feedback.

    This is different, they've reached out to the community, asked for our opinion. Going against the community now will just lead to more negative publicity, with the amount of bad press they've got over the last few months. This is the last thing they need. Valencia won and......

    giphy_25.gif
  • RadioShaq
    21271 posts Moderator
    If everyone voted for him why shouldn’t he win?
  • mHazard
    13787 posts Has That Special Something
    Right back position should be some CB player
    RadioShaq wrote: »
    If everyone voted for him why shouldn’t he win?

    Because there are actually more deserving players to choose from, when you put real life performances on line.

    The problem with this new TOTY selection for me is that players like say Kroos will now be left out because he isn't "useful" in this game despite being one of the best midfielders IRL.

    Sweaty bastardos everywhere...
  • sunderland
    1497 posts Play-Off Hero
    Yes
    mHazard wrote: »
    RadioShaq wrote: »
    If everyone voted for him why shouldn’t he win?

    Because there are actually more deserving players to choose from, when you put real life performances on line.

    The problem with this new TOTY selection for me is that players like say Kroos will now be left out because he isn't "useful" in this game despite being one of the best midfielders IRL.

    Sweaty bastardos everywhere...

    Literally no one has picked their TOTY like that
  • Hicksy2011
    19138 posts World Class
    No
    mHazard wrote: »
    RadioShaq wrote: »
    If everyone voted for him why shouldn’t he win?

    Because there are actually more deserving players to choose from, when you put real life performances on line.

    The problem with this new TOTY selection for me is that players like say Kroos will now be left out because he isn't "useful" in this game despite being one of the best midfielders IRL.

    Sweaty bastardos everywhere...

    I was really looking forward to Kroos, this is a real shame
  • Pughy30
    30878 posts National Team Captain
    No
    sunderland wrote: »
    mHazard wrote: »
    RadioShaq wrote: »
    If everyone voted for him why shouldn’t he win?

    Because there are actually more deserving players to choose from, when you put real life performances on line.

    The problem with this new TOTY selection for me is that players like say Kroos will now be left out because he isn't "useful" in this game despite being one of the best midfielders IRL.

    Sweaty bastardos everywhere...

    Literally no one has picked their TOTY like that

    People have Isco in their midfield how can you say this TOTY is being taken serious
  • i2-TempZ-2i
    7958 posts League Winner
    Yes
    Salty people just mad because their favourite RB didn't win, let me ask you all a question, if Kimmich won instead would this be another thread asking "should kimmich be in fifa 18 toty" or is it just the hate that everyone seems to have for united?
  • Smudge
    5715 posts Big Money Move
    Right back position should be some CB player
    People take TOTY way too seriously, would much prefer having 11 fun players for FUT
  • mHazard
    13787 posts Has That Special Something
    Right back position should be some CB player
    Hicksy2011 wrote: »
    mHazard wrote: »
    RadioShaq wrote: »
    If everyone voted for him why shouldn’t he win?

    Because there are actually more deserving players to choose from, when you put real life performances on line.

    The problem with this new TOTY selection for me is that players like say Kroos will now be left out because he isn't "useful" in this game despite being one of the best midfielders IRL.

    Sweaty bastardos everywhere...

    I was really looking forward to Kroos, this is a real shame

    IKR, there is reason why Kroos doesn't get informs and that is because he absolutely obeys the instructions he is given, and does wonderful job at the role he is commanded, which is more defensive that he probably would not like, being as talented in the offense as he is.

    You can try to find who Real Madrid players tell is the most important player. Same goes to Germany national team.

    Take away Valencia, Kante, KDB or even Modric and put Kroos in!!! :angry:
  • madwullie
    6444 posts Big Money Move
    No
    Couldn't care less about man United or la liga or in fact any team apart from motherwell fc but it seems to me that toty should consist of the players who make up a team of the best players of that year in their positions.

    I don't pretend to know loads about continental football but it seems a bit unlikely that the best right back in the world last year played for a team that struggled in their domestic league and didn't perform well in the world's premier club completion.
Sign In or Register to comment.