SOLUTION to Formation changing

It's clear that the current chemistry system is completely outdated and that's expected when it's been the same since FUT 11. Nowdays everyone want's to play narrow formations and use wingers at st or cam etc.

So the Solution is for EA to grow a pair and admit the PES chemistry style is the way forward and adopt a system similar to it. What is the PES system ? it's simply that players have more than 1 position so a secondary and tertiary position.

So for example hazard would have his positions as LW, ST or CAM because based on Real life he is known to play these positions regularly or Messi could have ST, RW. A cheaper example would someone like Zaha who's positions would be LM/RM or ST. So in any of these positions the players would get the max chem however if you play them out of position you would take a massive chemistry penalty like 2 or 3 chem so Playing someone like Sterling at ST would be a chem penalty because it's not a familiar position for him. Also this apply's to subs as well where they would get like 3 chem if you sub them in a unfamiliar position.

Only problem with this is that it would change sbc's completely and actually make them a lot easier to do which is not what EA wants.

Comments

  • They have the pattern licensed, those from PES so if they will use it with no agreement from them they will get suited.
  • blackerLVP wrote: »
    They have the pattern licensed, those from PES so if they will use it with no agreement from them they will get suited.

    Yeah but they should still have people who can innovate a new chem system which is based on multiple positions
  • Mousinho
    135 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    How many packs did people open cause of totgs ST Ronaldo?
  • Diggy
    14657 posts Has That Special Something
    Mousinho wrote: »
    How many packs did people open cause of totgs ST Ronaldo?

    People that have him still formation change :joy:
  • blackerLVP wrote: »
    They have the pattern licensed, those from PES so if they will use it with no agreement from them they will get suited.

    Yeah but they should still have people who can innovate a new chem system which is based on multiple positions

    they should, but they dont.
    They have more staff now to bring more sbc, totw sbc and control and maintain the msrket so they can sell some more packs. Unfortunately they don't give a fu* about the outdated chemestry system....like said abouve, how many people have bought packs vecause of that ST Ronaldo?
  • Mousinho
    135 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Diggy wrote: »
    Mousinho wrote: »
    How many packs did people open cause of totgs ST Ronaldo?

    People that have him still formation change :joy:

    You can put him in any position from cdm to striker. The ones who change formations have more options with a ST CR7.
  • Gromit
    4523 posts National Call-Up
    edited December 2017
    Surely the ANSWER is players cannot be moved out of position. I mean the game should literally forbid you to move a LW to ST or LW to CAM. LB to CB, RW to CM.

    Problem solved.

    I'm sure it already forbids putting an outfield player at GK or GK to outfield. So seems pretty easy to code.
  • tzinc
    1605 posts Play-Off Hero
    everything they do is for money
    EA will not change this system because it generates money for them lol
  • Diggy
    14657 posts Has That Special Something
    edited December 2017
    Gromit wrote: »
    Surely the ANSWER is players cannot be moved out of position. I mean the game should literally forbid you to move a LW to ST or LW to CAM. LB to CB, RW to CM.

    Problem solved.

    This should be like draft
  • cawbrey2
    633 posts An Exciting Prospect
    Gromit wrote: »
    Surely the ANSWER is players cannot be moved out of position. I mean the game should literally forbid you to move a LW to ST or LW to CAM. LB to CB, RW to CM.

    Problem solved.

    I'm sure it already forbids putting an outfield player at GK or GK to outfield. So seems pretty easy to code.

    yea but playing cristiano and messi as a winger in this game, a game that is near impossible to use wingers in, is dumb. nobody pays that kind of money to play them as wingers and have them do nothing but cross it in all game.
  • Aspral
    3796 posts National Call-Up
    The entire point of UT is to make a team using their chemistry system and play with it. So you should technically see all kinds of cool mixed squads.

    Instead I'm seeing Bakayoko as a Striker, Casemiro as a striker and Martial switched 7/10 games in the WL to a striker.

    It's just arrogant to spend 1-2 minutes every game for some players switching formation, doing instructions and all sorts every single game...

    Just bind managers to a formation. If you switch in game chemistry goes down. So that if someone is losing 1-0 and they need to change attacking then they can but they get a punishment of chemistry.
  • maksi
    6650 posts Big Money Move
    Chemistry is there to make cards more valuable, they won't remove it.
  • Choepiechakie
    32819 posts National Team Captain
    They should just add, as soon as a player will be used in a wrong position, he will get 4 chem, no matter what, when you change it.

  • Napoli9
    1964 posts Fans' Favourite
    i only here for the name...
  • FrankieXXL
    54 posts Park Captain
    Multiple good ideas in this thread. If only we had an actual community manager from EA to talk to so we as customers have influance on the game development. Many game companies have that but not Fifa/EA
  • Notformeclive
    2492 posts Fans' Favourite
    Just scrap positions full stop, Hazard has brilliant stats to play as a CAM (wide or central) why should you have to pay 1m to play him there without being penalised.
    Yes people will play wingers upfront but they do anyway, just we won't have to sit around twiddling our thumbs while they faff about.

    Keep chemistry for linking leagues and nations in hybrids but you should be able to play players anywhere on the pitch, if there stats aren't suited to a position (ie Bellerin at striker) then they should perform badly anyway.
  • Gromit
    4523 posts National Call-Up
    cawbrey2 wrote: »
    Gromit wrote: »
    Surely the ANSWER is players cannot be moved out of position. I mean the game should literally forbid you to move a LW to ST or LW to CAM. LB to CB, RW to CM.

    Problem solved.

    I'm sure it already forbids putting an outfield player at GK or GK to outfield. So seems pretty easy to code.

    yea but playing cristiano and messi as a winger in this game, a game that is near impossible to use wingers in, is dumb. nobody pays that kind of money to play them as wingers and have them do nothing but cross it in all game.

    Tough ❤️❤️❤️❤️ pal.

    If EA says they're a winger, they're a winger. If they get an IF at ST fair enough.

    There's 4321 to play them as RF LF.

  • Choepiechakie
    32819 posts National Team Captain
    Just scrap positions full stop, Hazard has brilliant stats to play as a CAM (wide or central) why should you have to pay 1m to play him there without being penalised.
    Yes people will play wingers upfront but they do anyway, just we won't have to sit around twiddling our thumbs while they faff about.

    Keep chemistry for linking leagues and nations in hybrids but you should be able to play players anywhere on the pitch, if there stats aren't suited to a position (ie Bellerin at striker) then they should perform badly anyway.

    ❤️❤️❤️❤️ no.
Sign In or Register to comment.