Which of these 3 do you prefer?

Reckoner
151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
xEAaYvF.png

Ybqwj3f.png

aJHp11i.png

Comments

  • Reckoner
    151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Bump
  • Reckoner
    151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    Anyone?
  • MataOfFact
    428 posts Sunday League Hero
    They all look awful with those CDM/CM work rates..and 5atb is awful..

    Top team is usable with Vidal CAM, Tulisso RAM and a proper cdm at RDM..
  • Reckoner
    151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    edited October 2017
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    They all look awful with those CDM/CM work rates..and 5atb is awful..

    Top team is usable with Vidal CAM, Tulisso RAM and a proper cdm at RDM..

    Top one is my current team, what other Bundesliga CDM options are there? Vidal is a CDM in game, not CAM. Obviously know he can be position changed but not many other CDM options.
  • MataOfFact
    428 posts Sunday League Hero
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    They all look awful with those CDM/CM work rates..and 5atb is awful..

    Top team is usable with Vidal CAM, Tulisso RAM and a proper cdm at RDM..

    Top one is my current team, what other Bundesliga CDM options are there? Vidal is a CDM in game, not CAM. Obviously know he can be position changed but not many other CDM options.

    Guilavogui
  • Reckoner
    151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    They all look awful with those CDM/CM work rates..and 5atb is awful..

    Top team is usable with Vidal CAM, Tulisso RAM and a proper cdm at RDM..

    Top one is my current team, what other Bundesliga CDM options are there? Vidal is a CDM in game, not CAM. Obviously know he can be position changed but not many other CDM options.

    Guilavogui

    Thanks will try him out, I'd rather not drop IF Aranguiz for Tolisso at RAM however. For 4-2-3-1 to work you need CAM's with Pace and he has more than Tolisso as well as being the better all round player.

    Not sure why I'd want to drop IF Aranguiz ahead of Tolisso? Is it because of his M/M work rate vs H/M?
  • [Deleted User]
    0 posts National Call-Up
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • MataOfFact
    428 posts Sunday League Hero
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    They all look awful with those CDM/CM work rates..and 5atb is awful..

    Top team is usable with Vidal CAM, Tulisso RAM and a proper cdm at RDM..

    Top one is my current team, what other Bundesliga CDM options are there? Vidal is a CDM in game, not CAM. Obviously know he can be position changed but not many other CDM options.

    Guilavogui

    Thanks will try him out, I'd rather not drop IF Aranguiz for Tolisso at RAM however. For 4-2-3-1 to work you need CAM's with Pace and he has more than Tolisso as well as being the better all round player.

    Not sure why I'd want to drop IF Aranguiz ahead of Tolisso? Is it because of his M/M work rate vs H/M?

    Only work rates..you could easily find a different attacker on RAM
  • Reckoner
    151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    sonnyfilth wrote: »
    Just curious, is there any reason you've gone for this specific team?

    Because for that coinage you could make so many better squads, even with the same formation, it just doesn't look good personally.

    I like to play with players I like irl, so those being IF Goretzka, Lewandowski, IF Kimmich, Vidal & Alaba.

    That along with not being a big fan of many of the Bundesliga wingers made me go 4-2-3-1.

    The rest fit around that with Tolisso & IF Aranguiz having well rounded card. To be honest I don't pay much attention to work rates more the stats to see if they fit into the position I want to play them in.
  • Reckoner
    151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    sonnyfilth wrote: »
    Just curious, is there any reason you've gone for this specific team?

    Because for that coinage you could make so many better squads, even with the same formation, it just doesn't look good personally.
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    They all look awful with those CDM/CM work rates..and 5atb is awful..

    Top team is usable with Vidal CAM, Tulisso RAM and a proper cdm at RDM..

    Top one is my current team, what other Bundesliga CDM options are there? Vidal is a CDM in game, not CAM. Obviously know he can be position changed but not many other CDM options.

    Guilavogui

    Thanks will try him out, I'd rather not drop IF Aranguiz for Tolisso at RAM however. For 4-2-3-1 to work you need CAM's with Pace and he has more than Tolisso as well as being the better all round player.

    Not sure why I'd want to drop IF Aranguiz ahead of Tolisso? Is it because of his M/M work rate vs H/M?

    Only work rates..you could easily find a different attacker on RAM

    Guessing with the workrates 4-3-1-2 would be better with:

    Vidal, IF Goretzka & IF Aranguiz - CM x 3

    Tolisso - CAM

    Lewandowski & Werner - ST

    ?
  • Reckoner
    151 posts Has Potential To Be Special
    This better?

    IE17UzU.png
  • MataOfFact
    428 posts Sunday League Hero
    Reckoner wrote: »
    sonnyfilth wrote: »
    Just curious, is there any reason you've gone for this specific team?

    Because for that coinage you could make so many better squads, even with the same formation, it just doesn't look good personally.
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    Reckoner wrote: »
    MataOfFact wrote: »
    They all look awful with those CDM/CM work rates..and 5atb is awful..

    Top team is usable with Vidal CAM, Tulisso RAM and a proper cdm at RDM..

    Top one is my current team, what other Bundesliga CDM options are there? Vidal is a CDM in game, not CAM. Obviously know he can be position changed but not many other CDM options.

    Guilavogui

    Thanks will try him out, I'd rather not drop IF Aranguiz for Tolisso at RAM however. For 4-2-3-1 to work you need CAM's with Pace and he has more than Tolisso as well as being the better all round player.

    Not sure why I'd want to drop IF Aranguiz ahead of Tolisso? Is it because of his M/M work rate vs H/M?

    Only work rates..you could easily find a different attacker on RAM

    Guessing with the workrates 4-3-1-2 would be better with:

    Vidal, IF Goretzka & IF Aranguiz - CM x 3

    Tolisso - CAM

    Lewandowski & Werner - ST

    ?

    I like that less than what I suggested above. That's for me anyway
  • A5B
    3172 posts National Call-Up
    I like this first the most, but all those CAMs are better CMs. I think a combination of James/Muller/Bartels/Sabitzer/Forsberg are more suited to CAM. Although IMO, you should go with either 4312 or 41212(2) with James CAM, Vidal, Goretzka, and Tolisso behind.
Sign In or Register to comment.