[Closed] Silver Most Consistent But Never IF TOTS [2]

134567171
Aarong222
14671 posts Moderator
edited April 26
PLEASE READ
Welcome to the official Silver Community TOTS thread. I'm happy to announce that this is where the community can put forward it's suggestions on who you believe should be included in the first FIFA 17 TOTS. Please check the rules below before making suggestions and try and be civil in discussion. If you have any questions, don't hesitate to ask myself or @Chow.

Our deadline
April 24th

Rules
• 23 Players (Starting XI, Subs, Reserves)
• Players selected must have been consistently playing well throughout the season (goalscoring, assists, clean-sheets, etc) but have NOT received an in-form (TOTW, MOTM (any type), TOTT, Hero or Award Winner card) in FUT 17.
• Don't worry about excluding players that could possibly appear in any league Team of the Season.
• The roster needs a good spread of leagues.
• If a player appears in the TOTW before the final squad is complete, he will have to be removed from our selection.
IMPORTANT: All player overall and attribute ratings will be determined by the EA SPORTS FIFA team. We're only asked to provide the list of players and their suggested positions. The FIFA team will evaluate the positions after we're done.

Please suggest players in this format: Player (Club/League) - Reason

Please try to add as much information as you can, but avoid ratings with statistical formulas such as the Squawka performance score and WhoScored player ratings. Try not to keep quoting yourself as I will read all posts. Remember it's a discussion rather than a vote.
Post edited by Chow on

Comments

  • Aarong222
    14671 posts Moderator
    edited April 23
    FIFA 17 Silver Most Consistent But Never IF TOTS: Interactive Draft

    96721b29693a11f53eed7ab0e83fffe0.png
    2ef59bf926c80d02a919caa68fd20f58.png

    GK: Jesper Hansen - (Lyngby BK)

    LB: Theo Hernandez - (Deportivo Alavés)

    CB: Jan-Arie van der Heijden - (Feyenoord)

    CB: Viktor Vasin - (CSKA Moscow)

    RB: Emil Salomonsson - (IFK Göteborg)

    LM: Marc Schnatterer - (1. FC Heidenheim 1846)

    CAM: Graham Carey - (Plymouth Argyle)

    CDM: Soualiho Meité - (SV Zulte-Waregem)

    RM: Denis Bouanga - (Tours Football Club)

    ST: Francesco Caputo - (Virtus Entella)

    ST: Chris Wood - (Leeds United)

    GK: Danny Vukovic - (Sydney FC)

    LB: Piotr Tomasik - (Jagiellonia Białysto)

    CB: Lonrezo Gordinho - (Kaizer Chiefs)

    CB: Osama Hawsawi - (Al Hilal)

    RWB: Andrea Conti - (Atalanta)

    RM: Deniz Türüç - (Kayserispor)

    LW: Jonny Hayes - (Aberdeen)

    CM: Kengo Nakamura - (Kawasaki Frontale)

    CM: John Fleck - (Sheffield United)

    CAM: Ghayas Zahid - (Vålerenga Fotball)

    ST: Ángel Rodríguez - (Real Zaragoza)

    ST: Alfredo Morelos - (HJK Helsink)
    Post edited by Aarong222 on
  • Aarong222
    14671 posts Moderator
    edited April 22
    England.png Premier League
    CDM: Luka Milivojević - Crystal Palace (74>?)
    • 25 app | 7 goals | 1 assist | 13 clean sheets
    • Turned things around at Palace under the stewardship of Significant Samuel.
    • "Imagine a Jedinak who can pass and tackle and isn't sh*t. I feel so much more confident in Palace with him in the team." ~ @Alex, Palace fan.

    Germany.png Bundesliga
    CDM: Diego Demme - RB Leipzig (72>?)
    • 26 app | 1 goal | 3 assists | 9 clean sheets | 28 conceded
    Other: 78% pass acc
    • Appeared in 26 of Leipzig's 28 games. In his absence, Leipzig were "dreadful".

    Spain.png LaLiga Santander
    LB: Theo Hernandez - Deportivo Alavés (74>?)
    • 26 app | 0 goals | 3 assist
    Other: 2 MOTM | 80.8% pass acc | 2.1 tackles p/g | 1.6 clearances p/g | 1.3 interceptions p/g | 2.2 dribbles p/g
    • Joint highest rated defender (with Filipe Luís) via Marca ratings (1.56/3). For comparison, the highest rated player overall is Messi at 2.08/3. Reference: 1 is similar to a 6/10, 2 is similar to 8/10 and 3 is similar to 10/10.

    France.png Ligue 1
    ST: Steve Mounié - Montpellier (72>?)
    • 30 app | 13 goals | 3 assists

    Italy.png Serie A
    GK: Alex Cordaz - Crotone (68>?)
    • 30 apps | 2 clean sheets | 48 conceded | 98 saves

    RWB: Andrea Conti - Atalanta (71>?)
    • 28 app | 5 goals | 5 assists | 12 clean sheets | 31 conceded
    Highest rated right back by Gazzetta with an average rating of 6.30. For comparison, the highest rated player overall is Belotti at 6.83.

    ST: Andrea Petagna - Atalanta (73>?)
    • 28 apps | 5 goals | 6 assists
    • Earned a call up to the national team.

    Argentina.png Primera División
    CDM: Santiago Ascacibar - Estudiantes de La Plata (71>?)
    • 19 app | 0 goals | 0 assists | 10 clean sheets | 18 conceded
    Other: 3.3 tackles p/g
    • POTM. Journalists have spoken of his consistency since breaking into the side at 19.

    Australia.png Hyundai A-League
    GK: Danny Vukovic - Sydney FC (66>?)
    • 26 app | 15 clean sheets | 12 conceded | 73 saves

    Austria.png Austrian Football Bundesliga
    CB: Paulo Miranda - FC Red Bull Salzburg
    • 22 app | 2 goals | 0 assists | 12 clean sheets | 13 conceded
    • While the backline changes from game to game (Wisdom, Ćaleta-Car or even Schwegler), Miranda is always one of the first names on the team sheet.

    CB: Christian Schulz - SK Sturm Graz (74>?)
    • 23 app | 2 goals | 0 assists | 9 clean sheets | 21 conceded

    LM: Valon Berisha - FC Red Bull Salzburg (73>?)
    • 28 app| 7 goals | 9 assists

    ST: Deni Alar - SK Sturm Graz (66>?)
    • 28 app | 15 goals | 1 assist
    • Topscorer in the Austrian Football Bundesliga.

    Belgium.png Belgium Pro League
    CDM: Soualiho Meité - SV Zulte-Waregem (71>?)
    • 30 app | 1 goal | 1 assist
    • Was one of the most consistent players in the Belgian competition this season, played in every game and helped Waregem to reach Play-off 1 as a "smaller" team. Got the highest average rating (6.43) in Sport-voetbalmagazine, Belgium's most important sports magazine.

    Chile.png Chilean Primera División
    LW: Cristian Insaurralde - CD O'Higgins (67>?)
    • 22 app | 14 goals | 2 assists

    Colombia.png Liga Dimayor

    Denmark.png Danish Superliga
    GK: Jesper Hansen - Lyngby BK (70>?)
    • 28 app | 12 clean sheets | 29 conceded | 100 saves
    • Goals conceded is the lowest it's been for 25+ years (club record).

    England.png EFL Championship
    CDM: Stefan Johansen - Fulham (72>?)
    • 34 app | 9 goals | 8 assists
    Other: 84.4% pass acc

    CM: John Swift - Reading (68>?)
    • 36 app | 9 goals | 10 assists

    CM: Conor Hourihane - Aston Villa (69>?)
    • 39 app | 7 goals | 14 assists
    • Had a fantastic season starting with Barnsley before joining Villa in January. He has the most assists in the Championship.

    RW: Garath McCleary - Reading (72>?)
    • 40 app | 9 goals | 8 assists

    ST: Tammy Abraham - Bristol City (67>?)
    • 38 app | 22 goals | 3 assists
    • Joint second top scorer in the Championship.

    ST: Chris Wood - Leeds United (72>?)
    • 41 app | 25 goals | 3 assists
    • Longest time without a contribution was 3 games (once).
    • Named in the EFL TOTS. Named in the PFA Championship TOTY.

    England.png EFL League One
    CB: Mark Beevers - Bolton Wanderers (71>?)
    • 43 app | 7 goals | 1 assist | 16 clean sheets
    • Tops EFL League One in clean sheets.
    • Named in the EFL League One TOTS. Named in the PFA League One TOTY.

    CM: John Fleck - Sheffield United (69>?)
    • 43 app | 4 goals | 16 assists
    • Joint highest assists in the league.
    • Named in the EFL League One TOTS and nominated for player of the season. Named in the PFA League One TOTY.

    CAM: Marcus Maddison - Peterborough United (66>?)
    • 39 (4) app | 8 goals | 16 assists
    • Joint highest assists in the league. Directly involved in 41% of the team's league goals.

    England.png EFL League Two
    LB: Enda Stevens - Portsmouth (66>?)
    • 42 app | 1 goals | 7 assists | 17 clean sheets | 35 conceded
    • Tops EFL League Two in clean sheets and fewest goals conceded.
    • Named in the EFL TOTS. Named in the PFA League Two TOTY.
    • Skate.

    LM: Tommy Rowe - Doncaster Rovers (68>?)
    • 43 app | 13 goals | 10 or 14 assists, depending on whether you're asking the club officials or his Mum.
    • Key player in a Doncaster side that is currently winning the league.

    CAM: Graham Carey - Plymouth Argyle (68>?)
    • 43 app | 15 goals | 14 assists
    • Named in the PFA League Two TOTY.

    Finland.png Veikkausliiga
    ST: Alfredo Morelos - HJK Helsinki (65>?)
    • 30 app | 17 goals | 6 assists
    • 41.8% goal contribution.

    France.png Ligue 2
    GK: Farnolle - Havre Athletic Club (66>?)
    • 30 app | 13 clean sheets | 25 conceded

    CM: Téji Savanier - Nîmes Olympique (71>?)
    • 29 app | 7 goals | 10 assists
    • Joint highest assists in the league. On Sofascore, they have a Ligue 2 TOTW and in recent months he's made it into weeks 16, 18, 19, 21, 22, 24 and 27 (proof of consistency).

    RM: Denis Bouanga - Tours Football Club (65>?)
    • 31 app | 13 goals | 6 assists

    Germany.png 2. Bundesliga
    GK: Philipp Tschauner - Hannover 96 (69>?)
    • 27 app | 13 clean sheets | 26 conceded

    LM: Marc Schnatterer - 1. FC Heidenheim 1846 (73>?)
    • 29 app | 10 goals | 10 assists |
    • Second in Kicker ratings.

    Greece.png Superleague Greece

    Ireland.png SSE Airtricity League Premier Division

    Italy.png Serie B
    ST: Francesco Caputo - Virtus Entella (71>?)
    • 36 app | 17 goals | 9 assists
    • Highest number of direct contributions to goals in the league. 53% goal contribution.

    Japan.png J1 League
    GK: Shusaku Nishikawa - Urawa Red Diamonds (70>?)
    Last season: 36 app | 16 clean sheets | 36 conceded
    This season: 7 app | 2 clean sheets | 2 conceded
    • Named in the J1 League Best Eleven.

    CM: Kengo Nakamura - Kawasaki Frontale (74>?)
    Last season: 31 app | 9 goals | 10 assists
    This season: 7 app | 2 goals | 4 assists
    J1 League MVP (oldest player to win this award). Named in the J1 League Best Eleven. Gargantuan.

    RW: Yu Kobayashi - Kawasaki Frontale (70>?)
    • 23 app | 12 goals | 9 assists
    • Named in the J1 League Best Eleven.

    Mexico.png Liga Bancomer MX
    CB: Hugo Ayala - Tigres U.A.N.L. (74>?)
    • 36 app | 17 clean sheets | 23 conceded
    • Tops Liga Bancomer MX in fewest goals conceded.

    ST: Raúl Ruidíaz - Monarcas Morelia (73>?)
    • 24 app | 12 goals | 1 assist

    Netherlands.png Eredivisie

    GK: Brad Jones - Feyenoord (73>?)
    • 29 app | 16 clean sheets | 18 conceded | 64 saves
    Other: 0.62 conceded p/g | 2.21 saves p/g
    • Voetbal International rating of 6.57 (7th overall).

    CB: Jan-Arie van der Heijden - Feyenoord (72>?)
    • 28 app | 2 goals | 4 assists |13 clean sheets | 19 conceded
    Other: 0.68 conceded p/g
    • 9th in Voetbal International rating.

    ST: Ricky van Wolfswinkel - Vitesse (73>?)
    • 30 app | 18 goals | 5 assists
    • 45.8% goal contribution.
    • Norwich legend.

    ST: Enes Ünal - FC Twente (70>?)
    • 29 app | 17 goals | 4 assists
    • 47.7% goal contribution.
    • Fourth highest rated attacker after Nicolai Jørgensen, Eljero Elia and Kasper Dolberg.

    Norway.png Eliteserien
    CAM: Ghayas Zahid - Vålerenga Fotball (72>?)
    • 28 app | 8 goals | 6 assists
    • Third in VG ratings. Third highest "goals + assists" total in Eliteserien last season for a team that finished mid table. Helped to avoid relegation.
    • Directly involved in 35% of Vålerenga's goals.

    Poland.png T-Mobile Ekstraklasa
    GK: Matúš Putnocký - Lech Poznań (68>?)
    • 23 app | 1 assist | 14 clean sheets | 12 conceded | 73 saves
    Other: 85.9% save rate (73/85 shots faced) | 100% penalty save rate (2/2)

    LB: Piotr Tomasik - Jagiellonia Białystok (65>?)
    • 26 app | 0 goals | 9 assists | 10 clean sheets
    • Was the top rated LB in the league at the break (source).

    Portugal.png Liga NOS

    Russian%20Federation.png Russian Premier League
    CB: Miha Mevlja - FC Rostov (72>?)
    • 17 app | 0 goals | 2 assists | 12 clean sheets
    Other: 2.9 tackles p/g | 4.1 clearances p/g | 2.3 interceptions p/g

    CB: Viktor Vasin - CSKA Moscow (73>?)
    • 22 app | 13 clean sheets | 15 conceded
    • Vasin's great form on loan to FC Ufa saw him recalled to CSKA Moscow where he has earned a place in the starting eleven, as well as a call up to the national team.

    CM: Roman Zobnin - Spartak Moscow (69>?)
    • 22 app | 2 goals | 3 assists
    • Second highest rated CM/CDM/CAM on Championat (11th overall). Included in TOTW 4, 8, 12, 17, 20 and 21.
    • Along with his midfield partners, both gold players, Zobnin has been phenomenal in central midfield for Spartak, who are looking likely to win their first Russian League title in almost 20 years. Due to the competition for places, Zobnin has, on occasion, had to play out wide, but his stamina and versatility have seen him adapt supremely well.

    Saudi%20Arabia.png Abdul Latif Jameel League
    CB: Osama Hawsawi - Al Hilal (73>?)
    • 23 app | 13 clean sheets | 13 conceded
    Other: 90% pass acc | 1.6 tackles p/g | 3.2 clearances p/g | 2.1 interceptions p/g | 0 defensive errors leading to goal.
    • Has formed a reliable and consistent partnership with both Mohammed Jahfali and Abdullah Al Hafith.

    Scotland.png Scottish Premiership
    GK: Craig Gordon - Celtic (73>?)
    • 30 app | 18 clean sheets | 17 conceded
    • Won the league undefeated.

    LW: Jonny Hayes - Aberdeen (70>?)
    • 28 app | 7 goals | 17 assists

    South%20Africa.png South African Premier Division
    CB: Lonrezo Gordinho - Kaizer Chiefs (68>?)
    • 22 app | 4 goals |11 clean sheets | 16 conceded
    • 3 of the 4 goals proved to be winning goals.
    • Kaizer Chiefs have improved their league position and defensive record a great deal since promoting Gordinho from their youth set up into their first team. Won player of the month for September and October.

    South%20Korea.png K-League Classic
    LW: Jair - Jeonnam Dragons (70>?)
    • 25 app | 11 goals | 6 assists | (source)
    • 5 MOTM | 4 TOTW
    • He's been directly involved in 51% of Jeonnam's goals since his arrival last summer. Before he joined, they had only scored 18 goals in their first 17 matches.p

    Spain.png LaLiga 1|2|3
    ST: Ángel Rodríguez - Real Zaragoza (71>?)
    • 32 app | 18 goals | 4 assists
    • 48.9% goal contribution.

    ST: Joselu - CD Lugo (65>?)
    • 33 app | 20 goals | 2 assists

    Sweden.png Allsvenskan
    GK: Johan Wiland - Malmö FF (71>?)
    • 28 app | 13 clean sheets | 25 conceded |
    • Named in Allsvenskan TOTY.

    RB: Emil Salomonsson - IFK Göteborg (71>?)
    • 30 app | 7 goals | 7 assists | 5 clean sheets
    • Named in Allsvenskan TOTY.

    CB: Nils-Eric Johansson - AIK (72>?)
    • 31 app | 1 goal | 2 assists | 14 clean sheets

    LM: Tommy Thelin - Jönköpings Södra IF (66>?)
    • 30 app | 7 goals | 6 assists

    LM: Simon Lundevall - IF Elfsborg (67>?)
    • 29 app | 4 goals | 13 assists

    ST: Sebastian Andersson - IFK Norrköping (67>?)
    • 30 app | 14 goals | 4 assists

    Switzerland.png Raiffeisen SL

    Turkey.png Süper Lig
    RM: Deniz Türüç - Kayserispor (71>?)
    • 26 app | 8 goals | 9 assists
    • 50% goal contribution. Earned a call up to the national team.

    Ukraine.png Ukrainian Premier League

    United%20States%20of%20America.png Major League Soccer
    CDM: Kellyn Acosta - FC Dallas (69>?)
    • 30 app | 4 goals | 6 assists | 11 clean sheets
    MLS YPOTY and All-Star. Earned a call up to the national team.
    • Fourth in the MLS' "24 Under 24" rankings (source). A key cog in an FC Dallas team that achieved the double and arguably the best player in his position (source).
    • "10 is greater than zero in America." ~ the late Dino7. We will remember.
    • A key cog.
    Post edited by Chow on
  • Aarong222
    14671 posts Moderator
    edited April 22
    One player per league will be enforced unless there are exceptional circumstances

    A player will not be considered unless he has participated in 75% of his sides game-time. There is no leeway on this number.

    The aimed positional spread for the side will be as follows: 2 GK | 4 RB/LB | 4 CB | 4 (RW/RM/LM/LW) | 5 (CDM/CM/CAM) |4 ST. There is room for manoeuvre here but this will be the rough layout.
    Post edited by Aarong222 on
  • Paul
    1243 posts Moderator
    bump
  • Adrian095
    28056 posts Player of the Year
    Smh why Aarong
  • exzoo
    24867 posts Club Captain
    Türüç, Erdem Şen.

    1st page reserved.
  • Hicksy2011
    6821 posts Big Money Move
    wahey Aaron is back
  • Jaxite
    21521 posts Club Captain
    Yeah BOI!
  • Vinz_kingz
    11846 posts Has That Special Something
    1st page
  • Rumplefish
    17728 posts World Class
    Wow
  • Dawud
    14678 posts Has That Special Something
    3 goalkeepers :worried:
  • sned777
    10083 posts Has That Special Something
    I was working on what I would pick, based on what I've read so far.

    Keeping in mind the balance of positions and leagues.

    52692d5db00e78f37f135062657be686.png
  • Uberman656
    13659 posts Has That Special Something
    Vinz_kingz wrote: »
    1st page

  • Rulistening
    649 posts Sunday League Hero
    The Grim dog is back in town
  • Neckabob
    8020 posts League Winner
    :* well hello there. Here we meet again
  • Monkey
    8323 posts Moderator
    Knudsen imo
  • Notts
    2434 posts Fans' Favourite
    Carnage
  • edwinstree
    6504 posts Big Money Move
    Hello darkness my old friend
  • Ibte10
    1421 posts Professional
    He has risen!
  • UK_Cam
    334 posts Sunday League Hero
    "One player per league will be enforced unless there are exceptional circumstances"

    Rowe and Carey having incredible stats for midfielders and helping their teams to win promotion.
  • Aarong222
    14671 posts Moderator
    Hey guy's starting the list from fresh please add as much information as possible to the players in a brief 2/3 line para. Failing that stats at least in the format. I shall be slightly picky as to who makes the list as we have limited time available. Please read through the rules.

    Missed you all
  • Vinz_kingz
    11846 posts Has That Special Something
    Thank you @WFCBagnall for the thread. You did a great job and really appriciate it that you took your time, even tough you are on your holiday
  • Neckabob
    8020 posts League Winner
    Quick question(and last time): ünal eligible for you or not?
  • Eurocelta83
    384 posts Sunday League Hero
    Tell me we are not starting over and we can at least start where the last draft left off.
  • D14
    2935 posts Moderator
    Cresswell isn't silver right? @Aarong222
  • D14
    2935 posts Moderator
    sned777 wrote: »
    I was working on what I would pick, based on what I've read so far.

    Keeping in mind the balance of positions and leagues.

    52692d5db00e78f37f135062657be686.png

    Ive always liked you.
  • Hagman10
    11732 posts Has That Special Something
    calm down with the caps Aaron lad
  • Aarong222
    14671 posts Moderator
    Dawud wrote: »
    3 goalkeepers :worried:

    could be dropped to 2 but three is the aim
  • wheelerdeeler
    1316 posts Professional
    So, Bialkowski's gonna sneak in then, right? @Aarong222
  • exzoo
    24867 posts Club Captain
    D14 wrote: »
    sned777 wrote: »
    I was working on what I would pick, based on what I've read so far.

    Keeping in mind the balance of positions and leagues.

    52692d5db00e78f37f135062657be686.png

    Ive always liked you.

134567171
This discussion has been closed.